CIRCLES

Version on the December BULLY visual album copy posted by Ye to Twitter - meaning it is dated on or before December 23rd, 2024. Adds bitcrush over the chorus vocals, and an echo at 0:46. Samples "Huit octobre 1971" by Cortex. Played during the Grammy afterparty on February 3rd, 2025.

8 documented versions · Dec 2024–Oct 19, 2024

Arrange

🤖 CIRCLES [V7] · (ref. Don Toliver) (prod. Kanye West)

Earliest known recording

Dec 2024CDQ

Unconfirmed

2:42

Recording dateDec 2024

Session—

Key—

Tempo—

Versionsv7

🤖 CIRCLES [V8] · (ref. Don Toliver) (prod. Kanye West)

Earliest known recording

Jan 28, 2025CDQ

Verified

2:35

🤖 CIRCLES [V3] · (ref. Don Toliver) (prod. Kanye West)

Earliest known recording

Oct 14, 2024CDQ

Verified

1:51

🤖 CIRCLES [V5] · (ref. Don Toliver) (prod. Kanye West)

Earliest known recording

Oct 19, 2024

Unconfirmed

—

🤖 CIRCLES [V4] · (ref. Don Toliver) (prod. Kanye West)

Earliest known recording

Oct 19, 2024

Unconfirmed

—

🤖 CIRCLES [V6] · (ref. Don Toliver) (prod. Kanye West)

Earliest known recording

Oct 19, 2024CDQ

Unconfirmed

2:15

CIRCLES [V1] · (ref. Don Toliver)

Earliest known recording

—

Unconfirmed

—

🤖 CIRCLES [V2] · (ref. Don Toliver) (prod. Kanye West)

Earliest known recording

—

Unconfirmed

—

* date estimated · dot color = audio quality tier · lineage view shows how each recording descends from an earlier one.